This "Jolly Ball" arrives Reddit-recommended for chewers, tuggers and chasers. It can be made so even when it will get punctured, it will never deflate and it'll continue to float in water. "Generally speaking, rubber-dependent toys tend to be the most durable and safe for dogs. A good model is https://cat-toys-toys38184.webbuzzfeed.com/30178006/the-greatest-guide-to-japanese-dog-toys